Theater Online - New York Theater Reviews

Cast Members
Brian Seibert
Deirdre MacNamara
Jake Lipman
Daryl Brown
Fly Out Menu
Open: 04/28/10- Close: 05/08/10 Proof
Reviewed for By: Heather Violanti

Jordan Nash Wills ©2020  Deirdre MacNamara as Claire and Jake Lipman as Catherine in PROOF

Tongue in Cheek Theatre’s revival of PROOF is delicately nuanced, graced with fine performances and a clear-eyed dedication to the script.  Director Kristen Kentner and the cast skillfully balance the rueful humor and pathos of David Auburn’s script.  The end result is a production as eloquently streamlined as the mysterious mathematical proof that drives the play.

Auburn’s play, first seen at Manhattan Theatre Club in 2000, won the Pulitzer and Tony.  The characters are richly drawn if overly familiar types that provide meaty roles for actors:  depressed daughter, crazy-but-brilliant-professor, concerned-but-oblivious older sister, slacker academic/love interest.  The current ensemble attack their roles with gusto.  Jake Lipman finds both bitterness and compassion within Catherine, the daughter who gave up her own academic aspirations to nurse her ailing father, Robert, as  he slowly slides into madness.  Daryl Brown’s subtle portrayal of Robert, meanwhile, eloquently captures the character’s sly humor and bewilderment.  Brian W. Seibert is effortlessly charming as Hal, Robert’s protégée and Catherine’s boyfriend.  Deidre MacNamara is pitch-perfect as Claire, Catherine’s compassionate yet slightly self-involved older sister.

Jordan Nash Wills ©2020  Brian Seibert and Jake Lipman in PROOF

Director Kentner paces her performers well.  She balances the comedy and tragedy with a deft hand.  If anything, the production’s most glaring flaw is its scenic design, or lack thereof.  (No set designer is credited in the program).  The entire action takes place on Catherine’s front porch, but the scenic components here--a bench, bistro table and chairs, bamboo mat, and window frames--don’t quite form  a cohesive setting.  The lackluster set contrasts sharply with the clever music and sound design by Philip Rothman, who has fashioned some memorable audio transitions between scenes (listen for the hilarious recorded performance by Hal’s self-consciously awful band).

Minus a few glitches, this PROOF adds up to a memorable evening of theater.

Jordan Nash Wills ©2020  Daryl Brown as Robert in PROOF

Bridge Theater at Shetler : 244 West 54th Street, 12th Floor